All My Friends

About Us

All My Friends is an independent bookstore in Cortland, New York, dedicated to fostering a love for reading within our community. Our carefully curated selection includes new books, used books, and rare finds, ensuring there’s something for every book lover.

Founded by Haley Flannery in 2025, our cozy indie bookstore is nestled in the heart of historic downtown Cortland. Whether you're a lifelong reader or just beginning your literary journey, we strive to make every visit a delightful experience. Our shelves are stocked with bestselling fiction, non-fiction, children’s books, poetry, graphic novels, cookbooks, science fiction, fantasy, mysteries, and more.

Beyond books, we offer a collection of stationery, puzzles, gifts, and book-themed merchandise, making us a one-stop shop for unique finds. Our passionate staff is always ready with recommendations, ensuring you leave with the perfect book or gift.

Can’t visit in person? Shop for books online through Bookshop.org or enjoy audiobooks via Libro.fm. Looking for a thoughtful present? Our gift certificates make a perfect choice for any book lover.

Stop by our independent bookstore in Cortland, NY, and experience the magic of shopping local!

Why Shop With Us?

Shopping at All My Friends Books means more than just buying a book—it’s about supporting a local independent bookstore that values community, diversity, and the joy of reading. Here’s why book lovers choose us:

• Handpicked Selection: We carefully curate our collection, offering the best new books, indie bestsellers, and beloved classics.
• Support Local: Every purchase helps sustain a small business in downtown Cortland, strengthening our literary community.
• Personalized Recommendations: Our staff provides expert advice to help you discover your next favorite read.
• Beyond Books: Find a variety of unique gifts, stationery, and bookish accessories.
• Convenient Online Shopping: Order books from Bookshop.org or listen via Libro.fm.

Join us in celebrating the power of independent bookstores. Visit us in-store or shop online today!

Shop Online

Can't make it to the store? You can shop online through:

• Online Merch Shop! (T-Shirts, Sweatshirts, Totes, and Hats)
• Bookshop.org (books and ebooks)
• Libro.fm (audiobooks)

Just choose "All My Friends" as your bookstore!

Frequently Asked Questions

What types of books do you carry?

We offer a curated selection of new and used books across all genres, including fiction, classics, literature, contemporary fiction, science fiction sci-fi, nonfiction, children’s books, cookbooks, fantasy, mysteries, romance, graphic novels, and more.

Do you sell gift certificates?

Yes! You can purchase an All My Friends Books Gift Certificate for your favorite book lover at the store.

Do you accept donations of used books?

Yes, we accept donations of used books. It is a great way to help support your local bookstore. Please bring your used books to the store during open hours or contact us to schedule a pickup.

Can I order books online?

Yes! You can order books online through our partners at Bookshop.org and Libro.fm for audiobooks.

Do you host events or book clubs?

Absolutely! We host author readings, book signings, and book club gatherings. Stay updated by signing up for our newsletter or following us on Instagram and Facebook.

Can I request a specific book?

Yes! If we don’t have a book in stock, we can order it for you. Just visit us in-store or contact us via email us with your request.

Do you sell stationery and gifts?

Yes, we carry a variety of stationery, greeting cards, puzzles, stickers, and unique gifts perfect for book lovers.

Can I work at your store?

While we are not currently hiring, we would love to meet you and keep you in mind when future positions open up. Please stop by the store or write us an email to introduce yourself.

Why are book prices so high?

Book prices are set by publishers—not bookstores. We agree they can be expensive! But we do offer high quality used books which can be a more affordable option, and we're always happy to help you find a book that fits your budget.

When do new books come out?

Most new books are released on Tuesdays. It’s an industry-wide tradition that helps publishers, bookstores, and media coordinate releases and promotions. So if you’re eagerly awaiting a new title, Tuesday is the day to watch!

Can you order large print books?

Yes! We’re happy to order large print editions if available. Just ask in-store or email us a request.

Can you order books in Spanish?

Yes! While we primarily stock English-language titles, we can often order Spanish editions—just let us know what you're looking for.

How long do special orders take?

Most special orders arrive in 5–7 business days unless they are backordered at the distributor. We'll notify you as soon as they’re here.

Can I get books delivered?

Yes! You can order books for home delivery through our partners at Bookshop.org and Libro.fm for audiobooks. Ordering through these sites supports All My Friends Books and helps keep independent bookstores thriving—all while delivering books straight to your door.

Who decides what books you carry?

Our store buyer curates the selection with input from our staff, customers, and publishing partners. We look for books that will sell and books that reflect our values—like diversity, inclusion, and support for local authors.

How do you get your books?

Most of our books come from major publishers and distributors like Ingram, along with titles from indie presses and local authors. Books by local authors are sold on consignment by writers in our community. They are shelved in their respective genres, marked with a yellow sticker so you can discover them naturally while browsing.

Why are some classics cheaper?

Books in the public domain—like Emma or Dracula—often have lower prices because their copyright has expired.

Why can’t I buy a book before its release date?

Even if we receive books early, we’re required to wait until the official release date to sell them—or we can get fined by the publisher.

How are books organized in the store?

We shelve books by major genre—like fiction, nonfiction, children’s, and more—and then alphabetically by the author’s last name within each section. This makes it easy to browse by topic and find your favorite writers. We also have sections for New Books, Best Selling Books and Staff Picks.